Perceptiveness & Experience Shape Rapid Choices

Perceptiveness & Experience Shape Rapid Choices

If the time to decide is short, decision governance needs to improve how the decision maker identifies cues, matches them to experience, what they experience they match them to, and the quality of their prediction of action outcomes.

Expected Uncertainty to Unexpected Utility

Expected Uncertainty to Unexpected Utility

If a decision process is designed according to the expected utility (maximization) model, then the choice of an option is explained by it having the highest expected utility among considered options. Consequently, decision governance over such a decision process needs to help the decision maker predict and prepare for unexpected events in order to maximize utility.

Max(Utility) from Variety & Taste

Max(Utility) from Variety & Taste

If a decision process is designed according to the classical utility maximization model, then the choice of an option is explained by it having the highest utility among considered options. Consequently, decision governance over such a decision process needs to influence (i) which options are considered, (ii) how options are compared against preferences, and (iii) how preferences are formed.

Simple & Intuitive Models of Decision Explanations

Simple & Intuitive Models of Decision Explanations

An explanation of a decision will provide reasons for why the chosen option was chosen over others. In this text, simple and intuitive models are presented for how to organize information into an explanation of a decision. The models are interesting only as a starting point, before we go into more elaborate ones and in…

Explaining Decisions

Explaining Decisions

Explanations of decisions are central to decision governance: before changing how decisions are made, you need to explain how they are made; you need to explain why they need to be changed; and, you need to explain how changes that governance brings should lead to better decisions. So the question is: What is a good…

Decision Governance Concepts: Outcomes to Explanations

Decision Governance Concepts: Outcomes to Explanations

Let’s assume that there is a situation you observed, and you want to understand the decision that led to it – maybe there is something particularly good about the situation and you want to see how to increase the probability that this happens again, or there is something you would want to prevent from happening…

What Is a High Quality Decision?

What Is a High Quality Decision?

Is it one that led to the best outcome? Or one that integrates all the relevant and available information? Maybe one that is liked by a majority? If decision governance is followed to the letter, will that guarantee a high quality decision?  The quality of a decision depends on the following: The reason a decision…

Are Easy Options the Likely Choice?

Are Easy Options the Likely Choice?

How many options will be identified when a decision needs to be made? How much thought will go into developing a robust rationale for each option? Doing both of these takes effort. Unless there are incentives to invest effort, a decision will be made from one or few low quality options. That is a simple…

Business Processes Implement Decision Governance. How?

Business Processes Implement Decision Governance. How?

A business process describes how something is done by highlighting mainly the actions to take, their dependencies (including their sequence), the roles in the firm who do these actions, as well as what triggers the process to start, and how we know when the process ends. Business processes implement decision governance in several ways. It…

What the Organizational Chart Says about Decision Governance

What the Organizational Chart Says about Decision Governance

The org chart shows much more than who reports to who. It is one of few core tools for learning about the existing decision governance setup, as well as for planning and implementing changes to how decisions are made.  If you look across the org chart vertically, across reporting lines, here is what you can…

Incentives in Decision Governance

Incentives in Decision Governance

Decision rights will be exercised, and decision obligations discharged only if there are incentives to do so. If you need to make a decision and bear the consequences, i.e., exercise decision rights and discharge obligations, the only reason to do so is if you see how it makes sense with regards to what you want….

Can Decision Autonomy of an AI Be Distinguished from Malfunction?

Can Decision Autonomy of an AI Be Distinguished from Malfunction?

I wrote in another note (here) that AI cannot decide autonomously because it does not have self-made preferences. I argued that its preferences are always a reflection of those that its designers wanted it to exhibit, or that reflect patterns in training data.  The irony with this argument is that if an AI is making…

Decision Responsibilities in Decision Governance

Decision Responsibilities in Decision Governance

Being entitled to make decisions carries with it the responsibility for outcomes of actions that the decisions led to. Accountability can be implemented through decision governance by defining responsibilities for outcomes of decisions. The idea that decision responsibilities are the counterpart to decision rights is easy to understand. However, defining useful decision responsibilities involves finding…

Role of Decision Rights in Decision Governance

Role of Decision Rights in Decision Governance

Decision rights are entitlements to act in a certain way and have access to specific information and resources required to make decisions. An executive may be asked to decide if an investment should be made or not, a manager may be deciding between candidates to hire – both are entitlements to make a decision.  The…

Decision Governance Concepts: Situations, Actions, Commitments and Decisions

Decision Governance Concepts: Situations, Actions, Commitments and Decisions

This is the first of several notes which will introduce concepts necessary to design and do decision governance. The aim is to develop a more precise idea of what decision governance is, how it works, and what it means to design it and evaluate its benefits and costs.  The focus in this first note is…

How Much Decision Governance Is Enough?

How Much Decision Governance Is Enough?

There are three ways to think about how much decision governance to do. I will call them  The “overall value” approach consists of comparing an estimate of benefits of all decision governance in place, with the costs of complying with it. Benefits include: Both of the above can be attributed to decision governance only if…

When Is Decision Governance Needed?

When Is Decision Governance Needed?

How can you tell if there is a need to do anything to influence how decisions are made, that is, to govern decisions? If any of the following apply, then it is worth investing effort to improve how decisions are made. 

How to Spot Decisions in the Wild?

How to Spot Decisions in the Wild?

A decision is a commitment to a course of action. There is no way to see commitment, which is a problem if you want to spot decisions. Instead, you can see actions people take, and infer from that what they may have committed to – note that you are inferring what they may think or…

Who Is Responsible for Decision Governance in a Firm?

Who Is Responsible for Decision Governance in a Firm?

The corporate function or group will usually have in its scope to decide how decision governance works in a firm. Key design decisions they will make involve who can design how decisions are made, how they can do so, including how to handle changes to, exceptions, and incidents related to how decisions are made.  When…

When is Decision Governance Valuable?

When is Decision Governance Valuable?

Decision governance consists of defining how decisions should be made, and auditing that the processes for doing so are in fact applied. While it often seems like decisions are simply made, and there isn’t much to govern, this is incorrect. It is possible to completely change how to think about decisions, in particular in terms…

Can Decision Governance Be a Source of Competitive Advantage?

Can Decision Governance Be a Source of Competitive Advantage?

Decision governance puts constraints on how decisions are made: e.g., assess impacts of decision options before picking one, estimate probabilities of outcomes of options, elicit preferences of decision makers, and so on. In other words, explain the reasons for a decision before deciding. If these constraints are a source of competitive advantage, then this means…

What is a “Decision” in an Artificial Intelligence System?

What is a “Decision” in an Artificial Intelligence System?

In the context of human decision making, a decision is a commitment to a course of action (see the note here); it involves mental states that lead to specific actions. An AI system, as long as it is a combination of statistical learning algorithms and/or logic, and data, cannot have mental states in the same…

When Is It Useful to Reify Decisions?

When Is It Useful to Reify Decisions?

It has been successfully argued in research on organizations that a decision is an abstraction [1], if it is defined as a commitment to a course of action. If I say that I decided to go skiing tomorrow, is this abstract or concrete? The only thing you can observe will be my behavior and the…

Can LLM AI Be a Source of Competitive Advantage?

Can LLM AI Be a Source of Competitive Advantage?

Let’s start with the optimistic “yes”, and see if it remains acceptable. Before we get carried away, a few reminders. For an LLM to be a source of competitive advantage, it needs to be a resource that enables products or services of a firm “to perform at a higher level than others in the same…

What Is the Depth of Expertise of an AI Training Dataset?

What Is the Depth of Expertise of an AI Training Dataset?

I use “depth of expertise” as a data quality dimension of AI training datasets. It describes how much a dataset reflects of expertise in a knowledge domain. This is not a common data quality dimension used in other contexts, and I haven’t seen it as such in discussions of, say, quality of data used for…

AI for the sake of AI :-) L’art pour l’art

AI for the sake of AI :-) L’art pour l’art

Just like l’art pour l’art, or art for the sake of art was the bohemian creed in the 19th century, it looks like there’s an “AI for the sake of AI” creed now when building general-purpose AI systems based on Large Language Models.  Let’s say that the aim for a sustainable business are happy, paying,…

Black Box Approach to AI Governance

Black Box Approach to AI Governance

As currently drafted (2024), the Algorithmic Accountability Act does not require the algorithms and training data used in an AI System to be available for audit. (See my notes on the Act, starting with the one here.) The way that an auditor learns about the AI System is from documented impact assessments, which involve descriptions…

Ambiguity of “Artificial Intelligence”

Ambiguity of “Artificial Intelligence”

Artificial Intelligence, if incorrectly defined, is even more confusing than it can be. Sometimes, it is considered a technology, which itself is problematic: is it a technology on par with database management systems, for example, which are neutral with respect to the data they are implemented to manage in their specific instances? Or, is it…

Which Problems Is It Hard to Design AI for?

Which Problems Is It Hard to Design AI for?

The less data there is, or the lower quality the data that is available, the more difficult it is to build AI based on statistical learning. For scarce data domains, the only way to design AI is to elicit knowledge from experts, design rules that represent that knowledge, parameterize them so that they apply to…

When Is a Career Resilient to AI?

When Is a Career Resilient to AI?

The short answer: careers that reward creative problem solving in domains with scarce knowledge. Let’s unpack that.

Perplexing Secrecy of AI Designs

Perplexing Secrecy of AI Designs

If AI is made for profit, then should its design be confidential? This choice is part of AI product strategy. The decision on this depends on the following at least. What is the relationship of each of these to AI confidentiality? Correctness: The more likely the AI / algorithm is to make errors, the more…

Can Opacity Be Solved in an AI Derived from an LLM?

Can Opacity Be Solved in an AI Derived from an LLM?

The short answer is “No”, and the reasons for it are interesting. An AI system is opaque if it is impossible or costly for it (or people auditing it) to explain why it gave some specific outputs. Opacity is undesirable in general – see my note here. So this question applies for both those outputs…

Opaque, Complex, Biased, and Unpredictable AI

Opaque, Complex, Biased, and Unpredictable AI

Opacity, complexity, bias, and unpredictability are key negative nonfunctional requirements to address when designing AI systems. Negative means that if you have a design that reduces opacity, for example, relative to another design, the former is preferred, all else being equal. The first thing is to understand what each term refers to in general, that…

Why Specialized AI Should Be Certified by Expert Communities

Why Specialized AI Should Be Certified by Expert Communities

Should the explanations that an Artificial Intelligence system provides for its recommendations, or decisions, meet a higher standard than explanations for the same, that a human expert would be able to provide? I wrote separately, here, about conditions that good explanations need to satisfy. These conditions are very hard to satisfy, and in particular the…

Limits of Explainability in AI Built Using Statistical Learning

Limits of Explainability in AI Built Using Statistical Learning

How good of an explanation can be provided by Artificial Intelligence built using statistical learning methods? This note is slightly more complicated than my usual ones.  In logic, conclusions are computed from premises by applying well defined rules. When a conclusion is the appropriate one, given the premises and the rules, then it is said…

Valuation of an AI Training Dataset

Valuation of an AI Training Dataset

If there is a market for AI training datasets, then the price will be determined by supply and demand. How does the supplier set the price, and how does the buyer evaluate if the price is right? The question behind both of these is this: how to estimate the value of a training dataset? We…

AI Growth through Expert Communities

AI Growth through Expert Communities

In the creator economy, the creative individual sells content. The more attention the content captures, the more valuable it is. The incentive for the creator is status and payment for consumption of their content. Distribution channels are Internet platforms, where content is delivered as intended by the author, the platform does not transform it (other…

What Does a Training Data Market Mean for Authors?

What Does a Training Data Market Mean for Authors?

If any text can be training data for a Large Language Model, then any text is a training dataset that can be valued through a market for training data.  Which datasets have high value? Wikipedia, StackOverflow, Reddit, Quora are examples that have value for different reasons, that is, because they can be used to train…

Preconditions for a Market for High Quality AI Training Data

Preconditions for a Market for High Quality AI Training Data

There is no high quality AI without high quality training data. A large language model (LLM) AI system, for example, may seem to deliver accurate and relevant information, but verifying that may be very hard – hence the effort into explainable AI, among others.  If I wanted accurate and relevant legal advice, how much risk…

AI Compliance at Scale via Embedded Data Governance

AI Compliance at Scale via Embedded Data Governance

There are, roughly speaking, three problems to solve for an Artificial Intelligence system to comply with AI regulations in China (see the note here) and likely future regulation in the USA (see the notes on the Algorithmic Accountability Act, starting here):  Using available, large-scale crawled web/Internet data is a low-cost (it’s all relative) approach to…

Algorithmic Accountability Act for AI Product Managers: Sections 6 through 11

Algorithmic Accountability Act for AI Product Managers: Sections 6 through 11

Sections 6 through 11 of the Algorithmic Accountability Act (2022 and 2023) have less practical implications for product management. They ensure that the Act, if passed, becomes part of the Federal Trade Commission Act, as well as introduce requirements that the FTC needs to meet when implementing the Act. This text follows my notes on…

Can an Artificial Intelligence System Decide Autonomously?

Can an Artificial Intelligence System Decide Autonomously?

To say that something is able to decide requires that it is able to conceive more than the single course of action in a situation where it is triggered to act, that it can compare these alternative courses of action prior to choosing one, and that it likes one over all others as a result…

Algorithmic Accountability Act for AI Product Managers: Section 5

Algorithmic Accountability Act for AI Product Managers: Section 5

Section 5 specifies the content of the summary report to be submitted about an automated decision system. This text follows my notes on Sections 1 and 2, Section 3 and Section 4 of the Algorithmic Accountability Act (2022 and 2023). This is the fourth of a series of texts where I’m providing a critical reading…

Algorithmic Accountability Act for AI Product Managers: Section 4

Algorithmic Accountability Act for AI Product Managers: Section 4

Section 4 provides requirements that influence how to do the impact assessment of an automated decision system on consumers/users. This text follows my notes on Sections 1 and 2, and Section 3 of the Algorithmic Accountability Act (2022 and 2023). When (if?) the Act becomes law, it will apply across all kinds of software products,…

Algorithmic Accountability Act for AI Product Managers: Section 3

Algorithmic Accountability Act for AI Product Managers: Section 3

This text follows my notes on Sections 1 and 2 of the the Algorithmic Accountability Act (2022 and 2023). When (if?) the Act becomes law, it will apply across all kinds of software products, or more generally, products and services which rely in any way on algorithms to support decision making. This makes it necessary…

Algorithmic Accountability Act for AI Product Managers: Sections 1 and 2

Algorithmic Accountability Act for AI Product Managers: Sections 1 and 2

The Algorithmic Accountability Act (2022 and 2023) applies to many more settings than what is in early 2024 considered as Artificial Intelligence. It applies across all kinds of software products, or more generally, products and services which rely in any way on algorithms to support decision making. This makes it necessary for any product manager…

Critical Decision Concept in the Algorithmic Accountability Act

Critical Decision Concept in the Algorithmic Accountability Act

The Algorithmic Accountability Act of 2022, here, applies to systems that help make, or themselves make (or recommend) “critical decisions”.  Determining if something is a “critical decision” determines if a system is subject to the Act or not. Hence the interest in the discussion, below, of the definition of “critical decision”. The Act defines a…

Algorithmic Accountability Act of 2022 and AI Design

Algorithmic Accountability Act of 2022 and AI Design

The Algorithmic Accountability Act of 2022, here, is a very interesting text if you need to design or govern a process for the design of software that involves some form of AI. The Act has no concept of AI, but of Automated Decision System, defined as follows. Section 2 (2): “The term “automated decision system”…

Does the EU AI Act apply to most software?

Does the EU AI Act apply to most software?

Does the EU AI Act apply to most, if not all software? It is probably not what was intended, but it may well be the case.  The EU AI Act, here, applies to “artificial intelligence systems” (AI system), and defines AI systems as follows: ‘artificial intelligence system’ (AI system) means software that is developed with…